This show was all over the place, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. I mean there were so many outstanding moments, and between them some unbelievable buzz kills depending mostly on whether you like the particular song or not.
The show started with unbelievably high energy with long overdue versions of Alumni Blues > Letter to Jimmy Page > Alumni Blues, Big Black Furry Creature from Mars. But from the Jim just about to the Melt, everyone wondered where the show was going. I mean Free Man in Paris? This had to be the request of someone close to the band because it’s hard for me to believe it’s going to become a regular cover. Nice song and all, but what’s next, You’ve Got a Friend? Summer of '89 is a tough song to get into, even though it ended pretty nicely.
But then they came back with a roar with Melt and Sloth, and everyone sat down when TTE started. I of course stayed on my feet and tried to rally support for the song from people around me. They poopood me until the “And as the carousel circles unceasingly,” line and everyone knew over the next several minutes how great this song could be. Thought it shoulda been the set ender, but they brought a really nice Golgi to send us into set break.
Expected the Chalk Dust, got a Chalk Dust. Wasn’t like most Chalk Dusts. Very experimental and totally out of the song structure. They did the same with the SOAMelt in the first set. Didn’t believe they were going to bring it back because they were nowhere near the structure of the song anywhere. And they couldn’t bring the Chalk Dust back to finish and Trey went into Fuckerpants. It’s an all right song and the crowd and Trey love it. It’s totally meh for me, but I know I’ve enjoyed a few. This wasn’t one of them.
I enjoyed the Heavy Things a lot even though it also isn’t one of my favorite songs. I was happy to hear Alaska, I was happy to hear all of the newer material at both Camden shows. But the Alaska didn’t hold me in the outtro jam until almost the very end that sequed into my most favoritist Phish cover, ASZ. Huge version and a nice place to put the Michael Jackson tribute that most people knew was coming.
That sequed nicely into Light which started off nicely but left me hanging in the outtro until it moved nicely into one of the nicest Possums I’ve heard in a while. Lots of crescendos, T&R, multiple sky rockets. One of my favorite songs of the night.
Show was over as far as I was concerned at that point. The Character0 is usually a great set closer, but this one didn’t do it, and the encore was meh.
I have no complaints about this band at all, even if in describing the show, I seem a little bruttal. You can’t describe outstanding performances without some contrast, and even though this show wasn’t as good as the night before overall, it may be a show to DL just for the highlights.
I love this band.