Anyone else feel that 12-7-97 is overrated?

i love 12.7.97

but i feel that both 12.7.97 and 11.17.97, although peak performances in their own right, overshadow GREAT shows from this tour that people may dismiss due to the hype over these shows.

11.21, 22, and 23 1997 are great performances, the 23rd being my favorite of the tour

11.19 is also an epic performance

^
11.19 gets overlooked quite a bit. No doubt about it! It contains one of my favorite versions of “Theme From the Bottom”

It’s great but if livephish had never released it we would not be having this thread right now. It’s just the easiest fall 97show to get, even more so than 11/17/97.

^

I disagree with that one.

I believe this one has always been talked about. It was one of the first shows I ever got. And a crisp sounding SBD taboot.

ive never heard anyone put this show down. this is my favorite phish show of all time. ive listened to it a rediculous amount of times. for me, theme is the highlight. treys solo knocks me on my ass every single time.

i knock it constantly.
first set is great, but the second falls on its face.
a