I just broke out my dusty Pharmer’s Almanac. I’m not sure which edition. It has setlists through the Island Tour.
Anyway, along with setlists, on some shows it will list attendance/capactiy, as well as ticket prices.
For example, at the Wetlands show in NY on 9/13/90, the PA lists an attendance of 450 and a capacity of 500.
Some other examples:
Barrymore Theatre, Madison Wisconsin, 4/12/91: 437/750
The Sting, New Britain Connecticut, 11/19/91: 315/1,200
Broome County Forum, Binghamton New York, 3/20/92: 1,500/1,500
Capitol Theatre, Port Chester New York, 11/27/92: 1,800/1,800
Roseland Ballroom, New York, New York, 2/5/93: 3,203/3,203
Bangor Auditorium, Bangor Maine, 5/7/93: 2,703/3,200
Stowe Performing Arts Center, Stowe Vermont, 7/22/93: 5,306/16,000
World Music Theatre, Tinley Park Illinois, 8/14/93: 5,643/25,000
The Centrum, Worcester Massachusetts, 12/31/93: 14,232/14,232
But not all shows after '93 were sell outs at large venues. Far from it:
America West Arena, Phoenix Arizona, 12/2/96: 5,818/10,000
Starplex Amphitheatre, Dallas Texas, 7/25/97: 9,515/20111
Desert Sky Pavilion, Phoenix Arizona, 7/29/97: 10,147/20,246
Riverport Amphitheatre, Maryland Heights Maryland, 8/6/97: 15121/21000