Cypress, without a doubt
I will always be partial to 1992. I was there, with my then gf/now wife, and I recorded the broadcast the next day. It was my first good-sounding live Phish recording, and I beat it to death.
It’s a killer show too. GREAT versions of Wilson, Buried Alive!, Harpua. The Antelope is outta this world awesome too. I think it beats the NYE’93 Antelope.
I was lucky enough to also attend '93 & '94. 1994 was Hot Dog night, but the show was weird … the sets were kinda short, and I remember thinking it was kind of a clinical show. I also got to attend 12/29/94, which of course is better than … better than food almost.