Halloween Shows

I tried to dig around and find older Halloween show threads but I couldn’t find any. We may as well just start a new one anyway.
Post your thoughts regarding all Phish Halloweens!! Remember, they go back further than just 94 even if they didn’t play musical costumes.

I’ve only heard the 4 costume shows, so I’ll discuss those in my usual rambling manner.
Halloween 94: I tend to put this show up there with 2/20/93, NYE95, and Big Cypress in terms of its greatness and universal appeal. At the time it was the longest Phish show ever played. Every set is also great IMO: first set has a surprisingly good Simple, a fun and funny Harpua, a best-ever-contender Reba, and one of my favorite Frankenstein’s ever (I love it as an opener; what a way to set a mood!!) Second set is The Beatles played by Phish. Enough said. Third set is the weakest by virtue of the fact that the other two are so great. I do love the Costume Contest in the encore; the groove they lay down is shockingly close to the funk of 97.

Halloween 95: This is, personally, my least favorite Halloween show. I know, I know. The first set is flawless. The second set is Quadrophenia, which I am still not familiar with though I think the Phish version is a corker. The third set has the longest YEM ever, and the rest is just good old fashioned Phishy fun. But I just like the other three Halloweens more.

Halloween 96: IMO the best Halloween show ever. Even ignoring all the musical import it had for the band, it’s just one of those front-to-back ass kicking shows that are indefatigable. I never get tired of any of these sets. I think this musical costume was their best ever insofar as it is faithful to the album and faithful to how Phish play their own material. The segue from Houses In Motion into Seen and Not Seen is one of my favorite Phish jams EVER. It is the pre-cursor to the 97 funk to me. The third set is the strongest of all the Halloween shows: Brother opener and the 2001 -> Maze are amazing.

Halloween 98: This first set is and always will be the weakest of all the Halloweens to me. I expect Halloween shenanigans and get not much of anything–no Harpua, no Colonel Forbin’s/Mockingbird, not even a BBFCFM or Sanity!! Or Icculus!! It just feels like the band got up there and played a normal set. Not a bad set, but compare it to the other Halloween shows and it is pathetic. I do really like the Loaded costume set, especially since they really gave it a Phishy spin. Sweet Jane and Rock and Roll are capstone versions. The Lonesome Cowboy Bill jam is weird and unexpected. Just a solid set of music all around. The third set is the most controversial Halloween set ever. I personally love this set though it is indeed short and bizarre. Crazy, out there, and spacey Wolfman’s Brother that descends into a mellow bouncing jam before Piper begins, which then semi-segues into the shortest Ghost ever because Trey flipped out or something. I don’t think we still know what happened here, do we?? Anyway, the whole thing apparently led to the Dark Side cover during the 11/2/98 show, so maybe it was for the best. The band took a risk and while if I was there I would probably be pissed off to be given such a freaky, short set, on tape I think it’s great.

I have heard all musical costumes but 1995. I know, I know…

A few spooky thoughts:

  1. 1998 is my favorite halloween show, front-to-back.
  2. The “Reba” from 1994 is my favorite version ever.
  3. The “Simple” from 1996 is my favorite version ever.
  4. The “Sweet Jane” jam from 1998 is, without question, in my top-5 Phishy “moments” of all-time
  5. I haven’t listened to the 1998 “Wolfman’s” in probably 6 months.
  6. I disagree with Greg’s assessment that 1998 set I is the weakest of all halloween sets. That honor goes to 1998 set III. In fact, I will gladly proclaim that I love ‘98 set I, including a great “Birds,” "Sneakin’ Sally > Chalkdust," and “Mike’s Groove.”
  7. If I had to pick 1 musical costume set to keep and get rid of the rest, I’d pick 1998.
  8. The “2001” in '96 is my second-favorite version of all-time
  9. Greg’s assessment of the 1994 costume contest laying down a fat groove resembling 1997 funk is spot-on.
  10. Of all the musical costumed show sets (12 of them), I listen to 1996 III the most.

I think 1998 is the weakest all around show, especially set 3. 10/31/96 may be the best Phish show ever, top 5 for sure.

10/31/94 I is one of the best sets ever for sure.

I think a 97 Halloween show would have been insane, but Fall '97 is amazing how it is.

also, I’m not a big fan of the 95 YEM…I like that clip in the 20th anniversary video though, where Trey does this weird little dance!

i go back and forth between 96 and 95, but i feel it must be said that the Jesus Just Left Chicago from 96 is probably the best ever, if not definetly top 5. i hear trey was literally hopping up and down while Grippo was soloing.

While 96 probably was the best musically…perhaps these Halloween shows could be judged better on the ‘being there’ experience. I could imagine 94 being the best to see…the costume contest…narration…the general buzz of it being their first proper halloween.

Also, Halloween 86 is pretty sweet! I thoroughly recommend checking out this show…they actually jam (which is odd for the 80s as this was more focused on compositional stuff). The Hood, Slave and Bowie are some of my favourite versions (!), believe it or not. I think I might put this show up on sendspace as a Free Music Friday…

I was at the 1998 Halloween and felt pretty conflicted about the show. The show the night before was EXCELLENT! It almost overshadowed the holiday sets. I like the first set, but nothing mind blowing. The Loaded cover was excellent, but not as good as the Talking Heads covers. However, the SJ RnR combo was unbelievable. The third set pissed me off. Definitly one of the three worst sets I have seen them play. Still a good two days of tunes. The SLC fiasco a couple of days later left a bad taste in my mouth, particularly since I turned down a ticket and a ride.

I also like the Beatles set from 1994. It is sloppy, but still exciting.

1995…need I say anything more about it?..

^ No you needn’t.

I don’t know why people don’t like the Quadro set a lot more…I think it is probably the most powerfully moving musical costume of them all. I like it better than the Remain in light set, but maybe that’s because the AUD recording doesn’t suck the way the Remain in Light one does.

And I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, I LOVE 10/31/98 SET III. LOVE IT. I would put the 11/30/97 Wolfman’s ahead of it, but probably no other version. Very experimental stuff that you can really lose yourself in. I really love the halloween shows and wish there were more, but what ever happened to my thread with the poll? I can’t find it either.

As far as the musical costume shows,
1998 > 1996 > 1995 > 1994

I love everything about Halloween 1998. Everything. Such a great first set, just completely fit in with the night before, which is very simply just as good as the Halloween show. Great ‘Birds’, which I am quite sick of these days, and the ‘Sneakin Sally > Chalkdust’ is top-notch. And a great Mike’s Groove.
The Velvet Underground set is my favorite of the musical costumes. Musically it is right up there with the Talking Heads, but I just prefer some New York punk I suppose.
Third set I find FANTASTIC. Definitely my favorite section of spacey Phish ever. I would take this Wolfmans over 12/29/94 Bowie anyday. Maybe it was since I was not there, and I am able to get into a mood to listen to it, but maybe that just all works into my advantage.

1996 has a LONG first set with some geat tunes. a BUTCHERED You Enjoy Myself sort of bums me out, and the Reba is kind of mehhh… And even to a certain point, my favorite tune Mockingbird is slightly on the mehh side. Although the Forbins rules.
Second set is all about the turn into a funky sound. The extra musicians really add a nice flavor.
Third set has a great 2001, Simple>Swept Away>Steep, and JJLC.
Excellent encore… I’ll always love Phish with horns.

  1. More horns, me likey.
    Hard to beat first set, until you remember you have two more sets ahead of you. Icculus, Divided Sky, Antelope, and Harpua all in the first set? I bet peoples feets were tired after this one.
    Then The Who, I really enjoy The Who, love the Giant Country Horns, but I just don’t think this is as great as '96 or '98. Personal preference I suppose.
    Great You Enjoy Myself opener in the third, but the set kind of fades away for me there. Nothing to write home about that I remember, but it has been a long while since I have given this disc a spin.

1994 is my least favorite, but thats probably just because some show is going to have to be last.
Once again a fantastic first set, with definitely one of my favorite Rebas.
The Beatles set is my least favorite of the four, just because The Beatles and myself don’t really get along. Never been a big fan, and I have basically learned a lot of the songs on The White Album thanks to listening to this Phish set.
Another great third set, with an incredibly nice Slave to the Traffic Light. And a rager of an Antelope to finish it off. Nice.

Funny, I thought Will would like the 98 show the least and grabs the most.

Double post because I’m a bad ass who doesn’t follow my own rules: I forgot to mention that as an all around release, the Halloween 98 show is the best because it includes good chunks of the excellent 10/30/98 show. I think this second set is one of my favorites!!

i have always wanted to hear them cover a ccr album. or ziggy stardust would fit the album cover aspect and they could have one hell of a visual costume/ stage show.

^I am telling you, Welcome To the Jungle would be bad ass…

BUMP!!

ouch

This is a must read!!! :o I grabbed this from PT’s own fenmanNC.

Enjoy! ;D

OK, so many on this board may know from my previous posts that Halloween '95 @ Rosemont Horizon is my favorite Phish show of all time. In fact, I can pinpoint my pinnacle Phish MOMENT as being that Divided Sky from set I (still brings me the chills everytime i hear it). That being said, it was also one of the craziest, scariest, and funniest nights of my life. let’s just say i had an angel on my shoulder looking out for me that cold Halloween night in Chicago…

Just to give you a little history…i was 19 yrs old at the time,
living in Buffalo, NY(my hometown) working at a beverage center(aka the Beer Store), going to a community college as a front to my parents, who had no idea how deep my Phish addiction had grown by that time. I had only seen a handful of shows at that point but my tape collection was growing steadily and my friends were diggin on them as well, which led to some pretty kick ass parties back in the day…thats a whole other story though…so I remember it like it was yesterday…waiting and waiting and finally…the announcement: Halloween show at Rosemont Horizon in Chicago!! I HAD TO GO! NO WAY I WAS GOING TO MISS THIS! especially since the year before they pulled off the White album, i knew it would be nutty…JOB OR NO JOB, CLASS OR NO CLASS, I WAS GOING TO THIS SHOW!!

i had no luck getting tix thru MO or on the phone…so i was bummin’…everyone was pulling strings trying to get me tix, cheer me up, etc…SO…exactly ONE week before the show date I come into work at the beer store and my boss, who was a relatively cool guy but i never really talked to about phish or music for that matter comes up to me and says (literally out of nowhere) “hey…you like the band Phish right? well, my wife’s brother lives in Chicago and knows a guy, who knows a guy, blah, blah…I can get you 2 tickets to that Halloween Phish show if you want, are you interested??” ummmm…HELLS YES!!! i got the tix overnighted to the office for free!! I COULDNT BELIEVE IT! IT WAS FATE! the boss let me off work for the next couple of days and I had someone (my friend Eric) to go with that was equally psyched!!! I had just gotten a brand new car in June (first trip was Red Rocks that year!) to take…so things were really coming together…only 3 days and a 9 hour drive to Chicago between us and seeing the boys on Halloween night! what would they play? how could they top the White Album? (damn, remember it used to be so exciting!?! )…at this moment in time, things seemed so smooth and perfect!!

think tiny pieces of paper and the cops … more to come soon…

ok, the day has arrived! spent the night before gathering up “supplies” (nugs, etc…these were Government grade, g7 or something but either way these were the best i’d had ever, white and stinky as hell) and other road trip ‘essentials’ (i.e. CD’s, food, gear)…my buddy had slept over the night before so we could wake up real early and leave. the road trip there was great! a little long but considering we had just gone out to Utah and Red Rocks a few months earlier, it seemed short and reasonable to drive 8-9 hours to see 1 show. parents will never understand this! damn, road trips are definitley one thing i’ll truly miss about going to see Phish!! always a blast to smoke, snack, talk, take in the scenery, smoke,listen to great tunes, etc… one minor setback regarding the road trip… my buddy couldnt get out of work the next day and needed to be back in Buffalo for work by 4pm. damn.

anyways, we finally make it to the lot at about 6-6:30pm after hitting some traffic driving thru Chicago to get out near Rosemont…we had our priorities… get into costume, find tabs, drink a beer, smoke, go into the show. we thought we were running a bit low on time but alas, the time change hooked us up with a free hour of tail-gaiting!!! things are grand! SO PUMPED!

costumes: I went as the song ‘I didn’t know’ …had a hoodie with DOUG written in big letters on the front with a pic of Otis Redding hanging around my neck, also had multi-color afro wig on…my buddy, went as ‘Frankenstein’ dressed in black, mask, the whole nine…

tabs: we scoured the lot in search of and it didnt take long, really, really, really good white fluff going around the lots that day. anyone else vouch for that? …so we find this dude and decide 1 each should be fine, especially if they are as good as everyone says…we between a couple of cars to split them up and ingest…my buddy has one on each finger tip…it was cold as hell, the vibe of excitement was over whelming in the lot and nerves for whats in store for the night are kicking in full throttle now…well, they dont call it the windy city for nothing folks, right as i go to grab my tab…WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSHHHHHH…it falls into a puddle between our feet…

…my friend and I look down at the what is now merely a tiny piece of paper floating in a puddle of water…look up at each other in dis-belief, look down at the tab still stuck on his one finger tip and immediately look around for the dude we just bought them from who by now had slipped into the crowd on shakedown…checked the time, 7:15pm…damn. we looked and looked for one more tab on our way in but had no luck, we had to split the one. little did we know that was the best thing to happen to us that night. the white fluff’s were for real…very powerful pills!!!

to be continued…

ok, so we split the tab, do a pocket/ticket check and head into the
show, freshly smoked and beer in hand…damn, it was cold, sleeting and of course windy waiting in line. funny to see all the costumes, trying to figure out what everyone was, laughing, smiles all around, voices swirling, WAIT! WAIT! WAIT! am i just toasted or is the fluff kicking in already?? just then, we hear a rumor that they are going to play Joe’s Garage and i turn to my buddy to say ‘that would be sssiiiiiccccckkk!’…my buddy looks at me, white as a ghost and
says, straight faced “DUDE, i don think i could handle that or talk, i think we are glad that one fell in the puddle”…and then smiled a bit and we both crack up…had to be there i guess…anyway, we get closer and closer to the door and i realize i left my ‘piece’ in my back pocket! D’OH! not a very good place to hide it i guess, but by the time I put two and two together and my thoughts are going a mile a minute, i’m in a cold sweat and cant stop looking at everyone’s face melting off onto the ground…BAM!!

‘Next please’ the security LADY says looking straight into my
soul…NEXT!!! nothing i can do but get my bowl taken at this point so i step up to the plate and just start laughing hysterically at the situation and my buddy does too…luckily it caught on and the security lady started cracking up AT US too and said “you guys look TOO happy, go on thru and have fun!!” …no pat down, no nothing.

whoa…close call indeed…turns out that would be the first of a couple close calls with the law that night.

we get in the show, got handed 2 chocolate medallions by this dude
dressed in a wolfman’s mask, who i later heard rumored was Trey handing out the candy…anyone else hear that??? anyways, we grab a beer and go to take a leak, ahhhhh only if things were that easy when your trippin…lol…basically between people watching and checking out how the tiles move on the wall, it took us about 30min to get a beer and pee! (funny side note: i drank the first half of my beer in about 2 seconds and took the rest of the first set to drink the rest) and we are on our way to the seats…another adventure but WE MADE IT!! Page side, half-way up…half-way
down…we get to our seats which oddly enough are right next to this
family of four…mom, dad, 2 kids…and US! just as we sit down…and TRY, i repeat TRY to get a grip …we hear this loud, loud, sound of a jet engine flying over head…somehow it had escaped us the Rosemont Horizon is right next to the Airport… the vibe in that arena was off the hook i’ll tell you. electric!! coupled with the ‘fluff’ it was almost unbearable…almost too much to handle…you could cut the electricity with a knife…so we start to freak out a bit with nervous excietment and again, BAM!!!..house music cuts out, LIGHTS OFF…PLACE ERUPTS! blue glow from the stage…

still going…

ok, so i’ll save my actual review of the show for another time. you all have the discs, you know how sick it is. the first set rips for beginning to end, the Quad is gorgeous, the YEM is monstorous and smashing the instruments on stage was the perfect ending.

a few funny notes:

after the first set ended and the lights came on, my friend and I sat down in our chairs and stared at the crowd for 35+ min, it was a lot like looking at one of those ‘Magic Eye’ posters…we sat in silence, jaws on the floor from the set of music we just got blown away by…right as i finally gained the courage to speak, i said “that was aweso…” and BAM que the lights again! on to the 2nd set! forgot to piss, forgot to get a water, forgot to speak…

during the second set, one of the kids that i was sitting next to was messing with my mind. for some reason, his dad told him they were
playing Jesus Christ Superstar which confused me for half the set but then the kid kept staring at me and smiling, tried to imitate me dancing and everytime i looked over at him, he would stop and pretend he wasnt doing anything. my god i thought, does he know i’m dosed out of my mind? can they hear me? did i just say that out loud? lol…great set! great pick! happy halloween!
…LOOOOOOOOOOOOOVEEEEEEEEE!!! REIGN O’R MEEEEEEEE!!!

ok, back to the story…
so, the show hadnt gone AS long as we were thinking it would…if i
remember correctly it was just a little after midnight(or was it 1pm eastern, dont remember off hand, doesnt matter) when we got out and if you remember correctly from earlier, we dosed at about 7:30-8pm which put us just past the peak walking out of the show…so as i mentioned before my buddy had to be back in Buffalo to work the next day, so of course if sounded perfectly fine to jump in the car, smoke one and hit the road…right?

riiiiiiiiiiighttt…

we got out of the lot rather quickly actually and jumped on the
highway, so far so good…trippin balls…i love listening to music after the show…and at that point we were still jonesin for some phish, so i put in one of my favorite shows at the time…12/29/92 New Haven, CT and just crank it! ROCK ON! follow the lines,
stay in between the lines, 8 hours to go… just then, i look in my rear view and start crackin up…“GUMBALLS!” i yell out over the music…my friend Eric, looks at me and laughs “gumballs??” he
says…“yes” i say, “gumballs, the cops…im getting pulled over”
…meanwhile, who knows how long this cop has been behind us trying to pull us over. we are clueless…lights are flashing, we dying laughing still until we realize …this is bad, this is real bad…new york plates, nugs in the car, 2am, trippin, and the cops…not good…not good…

…not good, not good…stay calm fenman, stay calm…you can do this. so i manage to cut across a three lane highway and skid to a stop which definitley in retrospect couldnt have looked too smooth and we wait, still giggling, dont know why…NOTHING FUNNY ABOUT GETTING PULLED OVER BY THE COPS WHILE TRIPPING, IN ANOTHER STATE!

just then i start panicking about where i put my piece and my nugs.
what if he searches us or the car? we would be screwed. then it hit me, i stuffed both items in a little storage area/CD case i had attached to my visor RIGHT ABOVE MY F’IN HEAD! and…I COULD SMELL IT…VERY DISTINCLY… AND IT WAS VERY CLEAR WHAT THE SMELL WAS! I DON’T THINK I HIT A SKUNK BEFORE OR AFTER THE SHOW!

we are SO screwed now i remember thinking! this is right about the time, the cop comes strolling up to my window and i roll it down very slowly, making eye contact right away with this dude who i now come to realize is an Indiana State Trooper, ahhh shit…I’ve heard the rumors about these guys…I’m dunzo… UGHHH!

cop: do you know why i pulled you over?

me: no sir, what seems to be the trouble? (very cool and calm tone,
meanwhile completely shittin’ bricks)

cop: where are you boys coming from?

me: uhhh…we were at a concert at the Rosemont Horizon in Chicago
(damn, should i have revealed this info i thought? what else was i suppose to say? your trippin dude, chill…btw, in case you forgot fenman, your trippin!)

cop: oh yeah, a concert huh? who was playing there tonight?

me: phish (DAMN! thats it i thought…its over, going to jail now!)

::: cop busts out the flashlight and shines it in my face, my friends face, then the backseat, and takes a walk around the car…and comes back to the window :::

cop: you mean to tell me, you drove all the way from New York state to see a phish concert in Chicago? you’re kidding me right?

me: yes (sheepishly)…I mean, I’m not kidding you. ummmm…

me(still): well, we wanted to do something fun for Halloween
and…and…this band…they always play…

::: cop interrupts :::

cop: you mean to tell me you wanted to do something fun for halloween so you drove from Buffalo NY (looking at my license now) to Chicago to see a PHISH concert??

me: well, i guess…i know it sounds crazy but…this band …

:::cop shakes his head and interrupts my blabbering ass again::::

cop: well, the reason i pulled you boys over was becuase you have a
headlight out…

me: oh really? (trying to look EXTRA surprised about having a headlight out because I totally would have never noticed in my condition)

:::cop walks to the front of the car…taps headllight with his
flashlight:::

and… THE HEADLIGHT COMES BACK ON!!!

cop: you know what son? looks like its your lucky night, i fixed it!!

me: wow…that was amaaazzzzing! awesome, thanks sir!

cop(cont.): hey, you know what? i saw phish back in Connecticut in like 1992 or something, my roomates at UCONN were real into them so they took me to check them out one time…they were pretty good actually.

::: i look at my buddy in disbelief, our eyes meet and we both cannot fathom whats happening right now :::

me: you know what sir, i have a question, was the show in December by any chance?

cop: yes! actually I believe it was! how did you know that?

me: I think we are listening to the tape right now!!!

cop: no! thats crazy! let me see it!

::: i pop the tape out of the player and hand it to him:::

It’s labeled 12/29/92 New Haven, CT. set I

cop: wow, thats it! that is a strange coincidence huh?

me: (testing my luck) do you want the tape, i can just copy it from my friend here again when we get back to Buffalo.

cop: no thats ok (hands tape back to me)…one sec, wait here…

:::cop walks back to his car:::

my friend and i sit in silence, afraid to even look at each other but
its obvious our jaws are hanging on the floor…i finally say, “this is fucking nuts! do you think he is messing with us??”

just then the cop comes back to the door and hands me a piece of paper keep in mind, i’m still trippin, just saw the sickest phish show ever, got pulled over by a trooper at 2am in rural indiana, i can smell my stash clear as a fart on a humid day and then …

cop: here ya go guys…

:::cop tries to hand sheet of paper to my shaking, sweat filled hand:::

:::note falls into a puddle::: (coincidence from earlier?)

:::hands it to me (also a puddle) anyways:::

cop (cont.): this note will get you guys home safe, if anyone else stops you for your headlight, just show them this note and you should be good. have a good night guys!

me: wow. thank you so much sir!

cop: be safe guys!

the cop drove off and we literally sat there laughing for about 5
minutes straight! damn, i had an angel on my shoulder that night for real!

we drove all the way back to Buffalo without incident and I actually dont remember stopping for anything the rest of the way …we just listened to music, drove the speed limit and thanked our lucky stars!

END OF STORY*****

there it is folks, hope you enjoyed…there are some good cops out
there i guess…or, we just go extremely lucky… either way, dont drive trippin after a show, with a stash and out of state plates, the odds were certainly against us…and even though we made it out, the lesson was learned.

i officially checked off one of my nine lives that night… sorry it
took so long to tell, but hey not a bad way to spend a day at work though. ha!

fate works in funny ways i guess!

i still have the piece of paper actually…it is a blank tkt and he
scrolled “checked headlight” along the NOTES portion and put his badge number and some other office info in there. doesnt matter, because i thought it was a piece of gold the rest of that night! i was invincible to the cops!

we made it home the next morning at about 10am…safe and sound, still buzzin, jittering, coming down, etc, etc…after i got home though…best.sleep.ever!

sometimes, i still cant believe this happened to me. sad part about it is that i havent talked to that kid (Eric) i went thru this with in like 8 years now. maybe we’ll catch up some day re-tell this story over a few beers.

In the end…I’m sooooooooo glad that other tab fell in the water…we were zoomin’ on half a hit, don’t know if i could have gotten thru it on a full one.

god, I miss going to Phish shows!

Cheers!

unbelievable.

Best story ever!!!

Good story, amazing luck. Unbeleivable.

i know i have said this along with a few others. the entire appetite album and november rain for an encore. page would tear that shit up!!!