Phish and the Hall of Fame

Phish General
#1

Is Phish first ballot Hall of Fame’ers?

  • Yes, Of course they are
  • No, they’ll make it, but they won’t their first year eligible
  • Nope…never…and I am a douche

0 voters

Ok, so with the pending inductions to the RnR HoF coming up on Monday, I decided to take a looksee at what the eligibility is.

An artist/band is eligible for induction to the Rock N Roll Hall of Fame 25 years after the release of their first record.

So, 2014 will be 25 years after Junta. Do you think Phish will be inducted in 2014 (or 2015 depending on the exact time line the HoF uses), their first year of eligibility.

(waits for someone to link a thread regarding this same topic that has already been created, yet was unfindable when I looked)

#2

I think they will make it at some point, but I am not sure they will get in their first year… My $.02…

#3

You stole my two pennies.

#4

I still have my two pennies!

(first ballot)

I mean, they’re the most important band of the 90s. Duh.

#5

:blush: I needed them… Sorry~

#6

Well, since we all have .02 to throw in, maybe we can bribe the powers that be to put them in on the first go-round.

So we’ve got .06, and building! :wink:

(voted, yes, but not on the first go-round.) :crazy:

#7

I’m with most that they’ll get in but not their first year. The way the Hall of Fame is heading is that EVERYONE will eventually get in. They force themselves to put in four or five artists every year so they can do the induction show but there’s really not enough Hall of Fame worthy artists out there to warrant them putting in that many every year. So we’re already getting borderline artists and other less-deserving bands who are being shoehorned in if only to meet the 4-5 band quota every year. Of course, after saying that, maybe they WILL get in their first year…they’re desperate enough for Hall-of-Fame-Worthy bands already.

I mean, for God’s sake, Percy Faith got in…he’s a one hit wonder!..If he gets in, then surely someone will put in Phish eventually. Not to mention that the Dead got in and lots of media sees Phish as the “next Dead” so they’ll get in for the same reasons that the Dead did.

#8

Well…if they don’t deserve it then nobody does.

My question…who do you think will induct them into the HoF?

My guess would be Carlos Santana.

My hope would be Prince with an epic Prince/Phish Tweezer -> 1999 (-w Vacuum Solo) -> Tweezer Reprise performance.

#9

Look at the bands that have been getting in…yes, they will get in. It’s not really that exclusive anymore.

#10

:exclamation: :clap: :clap: :exclamation:

#11

I wonder why Trey was chosen to induct Genesis? Maybe he is a huge Genesis fan…who isn’t??? :thumbup:

#12

Trey has made it clear how much he liked early Genesis, I think that helped get him to induct them.

#13

Add another .02
.08 cents?

Yeah,…Carlos is a good choice.
Him and Trey are pretty tight too. You can hear how big an influence Carlos is in Trey’s playing.

Carlos or Kid Rock is my guess.
I’ve read Kid Rock interviews where he mentions how much he loves going to Phish shows.
And it would be a more “modern” musician.

#14

:wave: Jay-Z?

#15

I don’t see how they are not inducted in the first year of being eligable. They have had too much influence not to be.
Their fests sparked how many other fests? They have influenced so many other bands, and have taken music to a whole new level. If they are not inducted the first year, well, the the Hall effed up.

As far as who inducts them:
Phil Lesh and/or Bob Weir

I think that woudl be extremly fitting, and very symbolic.

#16

Also I think the music press is trying to push these guys (Trey, Derek Trucks, Mayer, etc.) as the “new” guitar gods, so they probably want to get Trey out there a little more, add some “legacy points” or something.

just my .02

#17

WOO HOO!

We got a dime now… :wink:

I didn’t think about Lesh.
That would be really cool for him to induct them.

#18

I’m not so sure that having Phil and/or Bobby induct them is a good idea.
I know that Phil and Trey are homies and all, but it seems to me that The Phish have spent their entire career trying to distance themselves from the “Next Grateful Dead” persona.
And it seems that it would have all been for not to have members of the Dead be the ones to induct them.

Just another .02.

What are we up to now? .14?

#19

<----------------this guy. :wave:

seems like just about everybody is getting into the Hall of Fame.

they’ll be in there. maybe a couple years after eligibility.

i’m calling Dave Matthews as presenter mumbling something about playing guitar.

#20

Phish will be in for sure…

WHEN WILL RUSH GET IN?!?!?!?!?!? :think: