I’ve gone through the task of sorting out the Phish originals that didn’t appear on any studio release and then splitting them up chronologically into 7, hopefully mostly even, discs.
I use the term “discs” loosely because I’ve only compiled and burned this one so far. This one covers 1998-2004. There wasn’t a lot of stuff written during these years that didn’t land on the studio releases.
The reason I’ve done all this is that I get tired of some of the more overplayed stuff, and I hate to end up skipping it. I realized that I only hear some songs on live recordings, and that usually puts them alongside songs I seem to hear constantly.
It’s really an effort to maximize how I enjoy my Phish, and to avoid getting burned out on hearing, say, Tweezer for the billionth time. And let it be said, I love Tweezer, think it’s one of the great ones.
Okay ~ here’s what my disc 7 looks like. It ain’t chronological, but it is regular-logical.
- Bittersweet Motel (from Lemonwheel)
- Jennifer Dances (12-05-1999?)
- Windora Bug (9-08-2000)
- Driver (9-14-2000)
- Meatstick (IT)
- Spices (7-10-2003)
- Mozambique (9-26-99 w/horns)
- Spread It 'Round (IT)
- Mountains in the Mist (9-26-99)
- Discern (IT)
- Never (10-17-1998)
Not a bad disc. I think it does show that their enthusiasm was slowing down, but ultimately still good music.
I like that it isolates those songs. They’re always sitting in sets alongside things like Lizards and YEM, so I guess it’s no surprise that it’s hard to appreciate some of these songs.
Anyone have thoughts on the list? Maybe there’s a better version of something I could use? My IT is kind of a muddy AUD, so I can’t really hear the words that well. Also, Driver comes from LP-03, so it’s super clear and loud compared to the rest of 'em.
Anyway, I’d like to know what that looks like to you guys. I’ll continue this with a new thread too, once I’ve compiled vol. 6. I’m pretty sure that’s gonna be 1997 only.

