Quadrophenia Round One
Vote!!
“Sweet Jane” contains my favorite jam from all of the Halloween shows, cover or not.
Sweet Jane been veddy veddy good to '98.
Leave Fire to Jimi Hendrix.
So, that means it shouldn’t be played by anyone anymore, ever.
One of the only Phish covers that feels painfully wrong every time I hear it. Along with Johnny B. Goode.
This song single-handedly took 11.17.97 first set off of the “best-ever” first sets list.
Hmmm… I wouldn’t say that about Fire. I like it. Especially the early ones where trey really lets loose.
Blowin’ off some steam
I thought Fire would get a lot more votes. I’ve been a Velvet’s fan since long before I even heard about Phish and Sweet Jane was one of those songs that totally drew me into Lou and the boys. To vote against this song would be to vote against part of myself.
you gotta be kiddin me, sweet jane vs fire and fire only has 3 votes…
Yeah this is more lopsided than I thought.
But Phish’s version of “Sweet Jane” fucking rocked!
Fire is just a cheesy song, imo.
and its worse when Phish does it.
I’ve only one itchin’ desire, FIRE!
Upset!
Big time.