RD2: Melt(Cinci) VS YEM(MSG)

Old Kee Pa Best of 2009: Bracket Buster!
#1

Rd2

  • Split Open and Melt (Cinci)
  • You Enjoy Myself (Madison Square Garden)

0 voters

Round Two Vote!

#2

Cincy SOAM almost scared me it was so dark. LOVED it.

#3

YEM, easily.

#4

I love what they’ve been doing with the SOAM jams this year. Gotta go with this.

#5

YEM! ME!

#6

I don’t like the 2009 SOAMs…at all. That coupled with this juicy MSG YEM made this one a no-brainer for me.

#7

:thumbup:

#8

My first show at the garden and could not have found a more fitting song that encompasses everything wonderful about phish.

Sat behind the stage and to watch people’s faces as the guys from VT segued into the vocal jam at the end was truly a magical and humbling phishperience.

#9

MELT!

For me, the best Melt of '09 was better than a YEM which wasn’t even the top YEM for me.

Had it been Fenway YEM… :think:

#10
#11
#12

SOAM

#13

oops, i was listening to these songs but then i realized i was watching a 97 version of yem on youtube.

::finds 09 version::

::thinks::

i’m still going with the yem. the soam jam was sick but overall i just liked the yem better.