Rd5
- Sneaking Sally Through the Alley (Gorge)
- Tweezer (Red Rocks)
0 voters
Round Five Vote!
I am surprised Sally got this far… 
Stepping into the freezer
Ride Sally Ride…wrong song, but you get the drift.
I’m stickin’ with my girl on this one…for sure the best Sally of '09…still not sure this is the best Tweez of '09 though…makes my vote easier to cast 
Toughest one of RD5 here! Tweezer broke some magnificent ground, but Sally brought the heat in a few different ways…
NOT the best Tweezer of '09…A lot of these songs weren’t fitting, IMO. Thanks, Will, for all your hard work on these bracket busters, though. I just think a lot of different songs should have made it to the brackets…I know I can’t really nitpick, though. You have done a great job, Bill Reeves, AND it’s been fun voting!
Sally wins this one, in my opinion.
The OKP chose the songs, not me.
People in the minority will always complain. 
But if everyone agreed with which versions and which songs were the very best Phish just wouldn’t be the same. It’s part of what makes them so great in my opinion.
tweez nutz
Says the man who said this…
^FUCK THAT.
Can you play percussion that well? If so, do you consider yourself talented/the shit/not?
How disrespectful…
So, when did I do/say something to deserve that remark? I mean, correct me if I’m wrong, but I don’t remember giving people shit for liking a band/musician(besides Kanye West 
). Like I said, correct me if I’m wrong. Search away…
I happen to think that he is a damn good musician, and a damn good person too. He’s always been cool as shit to me, and very down to Earth everytime I’ve met him AND I’ve always enjoyed his contributions to SCI. So yeah, Jason Hann IS the shit, IIIIIMMMMMOOOO. Sorry…
Did you go through old threads to find that? I posted that quite a minute ago… Maybe one day I’ll go through every thing you’ve ever said in your life and find something I don’t agree with. In the mean time, I’m gonna try to enjoy what stale breeze is left around here lately. Maybe we all need Spring more than we know…
Will, what I posted was an opinion, not a complaint, or an attack. I even thanked you and commended your hard work. I just didn’t, and don’t, agree with all the picks. Fuckin’ Aye… I didn’t say anything about YOU picking them on your own. Sorry if it sounded that way. I’ve heard a few folks say they didn’t think some of these were the best versions of songs, and they didn’t get the normal debbie-downer treatment… 
rmp- I agree with you truly and completely. It’s true. You’re right.
Everyone else who has a problem with what I posted- maybe I shouldn’t have capatilized the NOT in “NOT the best Tweezer, IMO…”
Or maybe I should have posted IMO a few more times, or maybe, like, italicized them or something…
I, myself, just, like Sally more than Tweezer nowadays. 
Maybe it’s because I haven’t heard Sally a million times. Don’t get me wrong, I fucking LOVE Tweezer and always have/will, and that I’ve heard all the regular Phish songs a million times, but I seem to enjoy the rarer songs a little more nowadays. That’s why I enjoyed teh First Set/Second Night Cincy better than any of the other 3 Cincy sets (which I also got a couple 
's for) I mean, that feeling changes a lot.
This week, I feel that Sally wins. They were both great versions, obviously. Maybe I’ll take my next week and listen to all 52 shows twice more and come back with a better opinion.
Sorry, guys…
Woah.
So yeah… we got quite a race here.
Haha didn’t search just remembered you saying that.
I was just messing with you, man. 
Looks like we’re all in the “minority” now…
And Sally takes the lead!
Tweezer was more interesting
Sally
Sally for me. And my vote ties the race!