Personally I do not like the whistling
eh its cool to whistle
so yea with is the prefered
I don’t mind the whistling.
The only thing I don’t like with the whistling is it means they are going to repeat “Bag it, tag it…” a few more times.
By the time the jam starts in Reba I try to black that out… It’s just too much for me… When the whistling comes I am aware it isn’t quite over yet.
During 8/7/93…they climax at the end of the Chill jam…and go straight into Maze. The whistling is done over the top of the opening Maze groove. This is a really great show to check out!
Just another attraction in the circus of Phish, do it!!!
word.
Yeah, I’ve usually had it with the chorus by then. It’s not the whistling that bothers me, except that it means there’s another 8 or 12 "Bag it"s & "Tag it"s.
But even then it’s not like it’s bad, really … I like it when they leave it off, but I do like the bagging and tagging.
When I start feeling like I don’t like things like bags and tags, I figure I’ve got Phish overload. Must be, cuz it happens with other songs that I definately love … sometimes I hear Bouncing or Golgi or Suzy and I’m just SICK of it, even though they’re all songs that I think are truly fantastic.
But it’s like listening to the Beatles at this point … I’ve listened to these tunes so many times! But I still love them, and it’s rewarding to take a break sometimes and come back to rediscover all of it all over again (& again).
only 7 votes? come on! people have to have an opinion on this! It’s a verrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr-e-yyyyyyyyyyyyy importanted issued!!!ed
I went with. I feel like a broken man without the whistling.
How can you enjoy a “Reba” without the whistling?
It brings such closure.
It’s like in “Gin” when they return to the “Gin” theme! Er something.
I voted a resounding WITH.
WITH.
I love it when they leave the whistling off. Bag it tag it, drives me absolutly crazy, even more so after that amazing jam.
i am going with the whistling. any song that has ever had whistling, that i can remember, kicked ass. kazoos are a welcome alternative, which if everyone in the crowd had one would make for a hell of a whistling for reba or guyute.
I just went ahead and said without. Either way i don’t really care though, to be honest.
If everyone in the crowd had kazoos i would track down whoever distibuted them and lock them in my trunk… or someone elses
Yeah, no whistling for me, thank you.
I said WITH. The end of the jam is by nature so abrubt that I think the whistling really finishes the song. It pulls it all back together after an amazing jam.