Gin has it all; hose, funk, silly, and fun. McGrupp has fun and silly, but where’s the hose and funk? I dunno? Oh yeah, it’s in that big ol glass of bathtub gin.
The name’s Psycho! 
and Grupp is the choice indeed!!!
just broke the tie here…
obviously, mcgrupp is an amazing piece of writing, and it goes WAAAAY back…
but i’m a jamming kinda guy, and bathtub gin was a ruler from 97 on…
some of these early matchups really aren’t fair… shouldn’t it be more like “Gin vs. Fikus”???
i tied it up!
mcgrupp it is!
^ that the children are our future? ;OD
Gin has amazed me far too many times.
McGrupp is one of my favorite songs, too, but its not getting my vote.
I still can’t believe this thread is this close.
^ Told you foo! Mcgrupp should have been a 4
Had to go with a Gin on this. You know, as this bracket goes on, I have come to realize that there are alot of Gamehendge songs that I never saw live. Bummer!
Rhapsody in Blue takes it.
Hosemasters!
Um, I’m gonna go Gin, I think
Gin…absolutely. I mean c’mon… to me it’s not even a contest!
Are you effing serious?! People like McGrupp over Gin?! Gin is everything I love about Phish. Name a bad Gin. See?? You can’t.
6-30-99, 2-14-03. Now name a bad McGrupp!
It doesn’t matter.
The rightful winner of this thread will emerge.
Gin was my first love before Mcgrupp…
butt I mean c’mon, the writing of that song compared to Gin, no contest.
BIGB, how in the motherfuckin F is 2.14.03 a bad gin?
what are you smoking?
The 19th best “Gin” is still better than the best “McGrupp.”
on the anniversary of 6.25.97, I must say that that show’s McGrupp is better than quite a few Gins.
But I still like Gin in this contest.