Fuck it, this is so exciting I have to share more.
2001 Hail Mary - http://www.depauw.edu/news/index.asp?id=11760
Operation Frijoles
Prior to the 1965 meeting between the two teams, Wabash student Jim Shanks '67 scheduled a meeting with DePauw University President William H. Kerstetter, claiming to be representative from the US Information Service in Mexico City. During the meeting with Kerstetter, Shanks was able to convince the president to offer two full scholarships for Mexican students. To “seal the deal” Shanks asked to take photos of various points of interest on campus to show the “prospective” Mexican students more about DePauw University.
One item Shanks asked to photograph was the Monon Bell, in the Tigers’ possession after a 22-21 victory in 1964. The dean of the college was the only person on campus who knew the location of the Bell, but was reluctant to tell Shanks of its location. “I don’t know whether I should show this to you or not,” he said with laugh. “The last time I showed it to someone, they stole it.”
Taking Shanks to the second floor of a quonset hut near the football field, Shanks took careful notes that were provided to a group of Wabash students who entered the building and took the Bell back to Crawfordsville.
Shanks was on the Depauw campus at the time of the theft and was told by the Greencastle police to either find dates or leave the campus. Shanks and his friends proceeded to find dates for the evening while other Wabash students escorted their stolen treasure from its secret hiding place back to Crawfordsville. Greencastle police suspected Shanks, but his alibi was rock-solid thanks to the police themselves; he had been escorting DePauw co-eds all night. The Bell was eventually “found” by the Wabash administration and returned to DePauw the day before the 1965 game.
That Saturday afternoon the Little Giant football team made certain it was a short visit. Wabash defeated DePauw 16-6. At the conclusion of the game Wabash fans stormed the field, many wearing sombreros and ponchos, throwing taco shells onto the field and wielding posters congratulating President Kerstetter for the loss of the Bell and the two scholarship offers.